CUSTOM CAKES AND EVERYDAY TREATS IN BROOKLYN, NY

Bring your laughter and your stories too — We’re gonna celebrate good times with you.

— Inspired by Kool & The Gang’s ‘Celebration’

Life’s made of all kinds of moments.

Birthdays get candles, weddings get tiers… so, why not celebrate the F train actually showing up on time with a macaron or a chocolate-chunk cookie?

Welcome to the sweet side of the borough: cakes and cookies baked fresh, by hand, with heart—no fuss, no shortcuts, holding it down in Park Slope at 264 5th Avenue & Gowanus at 530 3rd Avenue.

Special Order Cakes

Signature Bestsellers

Events & Catering

Special Order Cakes

Signature Bestsellers

Events & Catering

Everything we do, big or small, is treated like it’s our only one. 
On point. On time. No exceptions.

Everyday moments – the ones that life are made of – may not come with confetti but have as many reasons to celebrate as the big ones.

Not every day is a wedding, a graduation or a momentous bash. But there’s lots to be said about getting through a hard week, having that long-overdue conversation with yourself or sticking to a promise you’re tempted not to keep it.

Cookies & Pastries

Cakes & Pies

Seasonal Specials

We Feel as If We’ve Won the Lottery.

Brooklyn is hands down the best place to be — an even better place than where we grew up – and it’s the real reason we created our boutique bakeshop here.

We’re infatuated with the way Brooklynites love food, their crush on flavor and details that go hand in hand with small batch made-by-hand cakes and cookies.

It’s how we bake. Always from scratch. Always by hand.

“The hand expresses what the heart already knows.” — Samuel Mockbee, American Artist & Architect

We Feel as If We’ve
Won the Lottery.

At Buttermilk Bakeshop, every treat tells a story. We’re deeply rooted in the Brooklyn community, committed to handcrafted quality, and passionate about celebrating all of life’s moments – big or small. Discover the warmth and care that goes into everything we bake, and meet the team dedicated to sweetening your world.