Buttermilk Bakeshop

Misspelled the birthday name

Sent a picture of the cake we wanted and it was Perfect.My daughters 30 birthday was great and the cake was the center of attraction...

They make the best cakes, especially their chocolate cake that’s moist and buttery. I’m not a cake lover, but they are our go to place for all occasions that require a cake. Seems expensive but the cakes are very tall and also rich, so they go a long way.

We ordered an 8” Confetti Birthday cake for my daughter’s birthday dinner for 13 guests. It was so delicious and we had cake to enjoy for days after!

I had a delicious cake prepared for my husband’s birthday. I thought of a cake at last minute and Buttermilk was able to prepare the cake in a day and a half. It was delicious and beautiful. I would definitely use them again.

We had Buttermilk cater our wedding and it was a huge success! Our guests raved about the dessert table; everything was absolutely delicious and beautifully made. Thank you Buttermilk Bakeshop!!!

We have ordered primarily cupcakes for school events from Buttermilk. This time, we ordered Push-Up cupcakes from their 3rd Ave Bakery, and they were a hit. When you order online there is a chat feature whose transcript is saved with your order, which I find convenient and helpful - all documented. Dietary restrictions: Nut free cupcakes (although not a nut free facility)

I had to update an order to make my custom cake bigger via the chat feature, and it could not have been easier. The cake for my boyfriend’s birthday was beautiful and everyone loved it. The candles were gorgeous. The shop where I picked it up in person was adorable and I will definitely be coming back. Thank you so much!

Excellent overall 👌🏽

The most beautiful (and delicious) flower cupcakes! Perfect for a birthday party! Amazing custom cakes too!