Brooklyn, NY (347)987-3941   social facebook box white 256  social twitter box white 64  instagram

Your Cart

Quantity Price Total
$0.00
Proceed to Checkout
Your cart is empty

Shop The Bake Shop

Apricot Bars

Apricot Bars

Not...
Assorted Cookies by the Dozen

Assorted Cookies by the Dozen

A...
Black & White Cookies

Black & White Cookies

A...
Fudge Brownies

Fudge Brownies

Half...
Harvest Cookies

Harvest Cookies

Looking...
Lemon Bars

Lemon Bars

Tart...
OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS

OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS

Half...
Peanut Butter Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookies

Half...
Raspberry Linzers

Raspberry Linzers

Half...
Red Velvet Cookie

Red Velvet Cookie

   Add...
SALTED CARAMEL SNICKERDOODLES

SALTED CARAMEL SNICKERDOODLES

These...
Salted Nutella Cookies

Salted Nutella Cookies

Half...
TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKERS

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKERS

Half...
Whoopie Pies

Whoopie Pies

   Add...
Wonder bar

Wonder bar

   Add...
  • Apricot Bars
  • Assorted Cookies by the Dozen
  • Black & White Cookies
  • Fudge Brownies
  • Harvest Cookies
  • Lemon Bars
  • OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS
  • Peanut Butter Cookies
  • Raspberry Linzers
  • Red Velvet Cookie
  • SALTED CARAMEL SNICKERDOODLES
  • Salted Nutella Cookies
  • TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKERS
  • Whoopie Pies
  • Wonder bar
  • Apricot Bars

    Not your average fruit bar: This shortbread based treat is slathered with fresh apricot jam and topped with a baked hazelnut meringue. Perfect with a cup of tea!

  • Assorted Cookies by the Dozen

    A variety pack of 1 dozen of our freshly baked cookies – seasonal flavors included

  • Black & White Cookies

    A classic New York fave! 

  • Fudge Brownies

    Half dozen, individually wrapped fudge brownies, studded with chocolate chips.

  • Harvest Cookies

    Looking for a healthy cookie you can sink your teeth into? Our chewy Harvest Cookies are made with oats, raisins, cranberries and flax seeds. It’s a cookie you won’t feel guilty loving.

  • Lemon Bars

    Tart and lemony - it's the perfect bite of sunshine to add to your day!

  • OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS

    Half dozen sugar cookies with sprinkles on top.

  • Peanut Butter Cookies

    Half dozen cookies for peanut butter fanatics (like us!). Peanut butter cookie loaded up with peanut butter and chocolate chips and topped with roasted peanuts

  • Raspberry Linzers

    Half dozen melt-in-your mouth linzers, made with ground hazelnuts and brightly flavored raspberry jam.

  • Red Velvet Cookie

  • SALTED CARAMEL SNICKERDOODLES

    These aren’t your typical snickerdoodle. Topped with salted caramel and with a soft, crisp chewiness, these cookies will have you singing for more!

    Price is for a half dozen cookies.

  • Salted Nutella Cookies

    Half dozen of these sinfully delicious chocolate cookies, topped with a spoonful of Nutella and flecked with coarse sea salt.

  • TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKERS

    Half dozen of our gooey chocolate chunk cookies (made with dark, milk and white chocolate)

  • Whoopie Pies

  • Wonder bar

  • Apricot Bars
  • Assorted Cookies by the Dozen
  • Black & White Cookies
  • Fudge Brownies
  • Harvest Cookies
  • Lemon Bars
  • OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS
  • Peanut Butter Cookies
  • Raspberry Linzers
  • Red Velvet Cookie
  • SALTED CARAMEL SNICKERDOODLES
  • Salted Nutella Cookies
  • TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKERS
  • Whoopie Pies
  • Wonder bar

(347)987-3941
260 5TH AVENUE, BROOKLYN NY 11215
 INFO@BUTTERMILKBAKESHOP.COM
  TUESDAY-SATURDAY, 9AM - 7PM / SUNDAY, 9AM - 6PM