cupiconUpcoming Classes

Private or public classes are a great gift idea for birthdays or grads!

French Macaron 101

French Macaron 101

$80.00

Join us in making fantastic Springtime macarons from scratch! Be the hit of the party with pastel shades in flavors including lemon, blueberry lavender, and raspberry rose. All items will be taken home at the end of class.

Summer Pies

Summer Pies

$80.00

Join us in making our favorite seasonal pies from scratch! Each team will make up to three types of pies. Invite friends over afterward – and celebrate 3.14 in style!

Luscious Chocolate Desserts

Luscious Chocolate Desserts

$80.00

Our kitchen is heating up! Join us at our shop to make molten chocolate cake, truffles, nutella macarons and other deliciously chocolately treats from scratch. 

Rainbow Cupcakes & Macarons!

Rainbow Cupcakes & Macarons!

$80.00

We’re coming together to make deliciously colorful rainbow cupcakes, and rainbow themed macarons! Join us and embrace all the colors of Spring with this fantastically fun baking class. All guests will leave with a box of 6-12 cupcakes & macarons.

Fresh In Our Shop

Stroll in, sit down or grab and go! We have you covered.

Rainbow Cake

Rainbow Cake

Celebrate pride year round! 

Triple Chocolate Chunk

Triple Chocolate Chunk

Because sometimes you just need a good cookie...

Cupcakes & Macarons

Cupcakes & Macarons

WE won't make you share...but Frenchie might!

Our Menu

Cakes, cookies, bars and more!

Triple Chocolate Chunk

Triple Chocolate Chunk

What's better than a chocolate chip cookie? A triple chocolate chip cookie! Made with milk,dark, and white chocolate chips and a slight touch of salt on top to pull the flavors together. Our classic! 

Butterscotch

Butterscotch

Butterscotch cookie topped with gooey toasted marshmallow!  

Sprinkle Cookie

Sprinkle Cookie

A festive addition to any boxed assortment of cookies or on its own, our colorful sprinkle cookie is a favorite with kids and nostalgic adults. Soft sugar cookie dough generously coated with sprinkles and baked with love. 

 

Salted Caramel Snickerdoodles

Salted Caramel Snickerdoodles

Chewy cinnamon cookie heavily drizzled with salted caramel and topped with pecans. Staff favorite! 

Salted Nutella Cookies

Salted Nutella Cookies

Our of our richest, most chocolate-y options! A moist dark chocolate cookie topped with a dollop of hazelnut Nutella spread and sprinkled with flakes of sea salt. Customers routinely tell us this is their favorite cookie at the Bakeshop!

Peanut Butter Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookies

Thick peanut butter taste with an extra surprise: chocolate chips! Topped with peanuts. 

 

Harvest Cookies

Harvest Cookies

Looking for a healthy cookie you can sink your teeth into? Our chewy Harvest Cookies are made with oats, raisins, cranberries and flax seeds. It’s a cookie you won’t feel guilty loving.

Key Lime

Key Lime

Because it's hard to hold a slice of pie in your hand! Our tart key lime drizzle makes this cookie a perfect pair with a cup of coffee.

Fudge Brownies

Fudge Brownies

Dark, fudge brownies studded with chocolate chips

Raspberry Linzers

Raspberry Linzers

Melt-in-your mouth linzers, made with ground hazelnuts and brightly flavored raspberry jam.

Black & White Cookies

Black & White Cookies

A must-have in any New York bakery. Moist sugar cookie base topped with painted black and white frosting

Lemon Bars

Lemon Bars

Tart and lemony - it's the perfect bite of sunshine to add to your day!

Apricot Bars

Apricot Bars

Not your average fruit bar: This shortbread based treat is slathered with fresh apricot jam and topped with a baked hazelnut meringue. Perfect with a cup of tea!

S'mores Bar

S'mores Bar

Why wait for camp outs?!

Whoopie Pies

Whoopie Pies

Cannoli cream sandwiched between two pieces of heart-shaped and moist red velvet cake! A decadent treat for you and your loved ones. 

Red Velvet Cookie

Red Velvet Cookie

Who says red velvet is only for cupcakes and cakes? Cookie made with red velvet dough and baked with a generous white chocolate chunk in the middle. Topped with cocoa! 

Biscuit

Biscuit

Delicious for breakfast or a snack! Just add your favorite jam!

Blueberry Muffin

Blueberry Muffin

Fluffy, crumb topped muffin studded with plump fresh blueberries

Pumpkin Muffin

Pumpkin Muffin

A wonderful mouthful of fall, year round!

Croissant

Croissant

The classic French pastry and a Buttermilk favorite.

Chocolate Croissant

Chocolate Croissant

Oh so continental! Buttery pastry and decadant chocolate... Breakfast of champions!

Ham and Cheese

Ham and Cheese

Not everything we do is sweet... We have a savory side too!

Scone

Scone

Just right for tea time! Fruited scones are a lovely change.

Monkey Bun

Monkey Bun

A delightfully caramelized pastry slathered with brown sugar, cinnamon, pecans and bananas

Nutella Pecan Pie

Nutella Pecan Pie

Dense chopped pecans, brown sugar caramel, and the best hazelnut Nutella spread makes this pie a fan favorite! 

Buttermilk Pie

Buttermilk Pie

Our namesake pie! Imagine a creme brulee dessert in pie-form! Glazed sugary crust above a custard filling. 

 

Fruit Crumble Pie

Fruit Crumble Pie

 Pie filled with seasonal fruit and topped with a buttery crumble! 

Seasonal Cupcakes

Seasonal Cupcakes

Assorted Minis

Assorted Minis

Check out our Sweets Menu for more mini treats!

Macarons

Macarons

Cake Pops

Cake Pops

Coconut Chocolate

Coconut Chocolate

Hefty heaps of coconut flakes baked with a chocolate dollop! 

Gooey Bastard

Gooey Bastard

We all know one. Have him in cookie form! 

Dark chocolate cookie with a candy bar baked inside, drizzled with caramel, and topped with gooey melted marshmallows and salty peanuts. 

Maple Apple

Maple Apple

Our favorite Autumn cookie - cinnamon and a hint of ginger with plump dried apples and a soul satisfying maple glaze

Custom Cakes

Nothing makes a special day like a cake made to order for your celebration!

Opening Hours

260 5TH AVENUE, BROOKLYN NY 11215
Tue-Sat 9am - 7pm
Sun 9am - 6pm
(347)987-3941 This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

About Us

At Buttermilk Bakeshop, we bake all our items from scratch in our open kitchen each day, ensuring quality products straight out of the oven.
read more...