Wonder bar Order Now! OLD FASHIONED SPRINKLERS Half dozen sugar cookies with sprinkles on top. Order Now! Harvest Cookies Looking for a healthy cookie you can sink your teeth into? Our chewy Harvest Cookies are made with oats, raisins, cranberries and flax seeds. It’s a cookie you won’t feel guilty loving. Order Now! Lemon Bars Tart and lemony - it's the perfect bite of sunshine to add to your day! Order Now! @buttermilkbakeshopny on Instagram!