• Featured Baked Goods

    Triple Chocolate Chunkers

    Half dozen of our gooey chocolate chunk cookies (made with dark, milk and white chocolate)

  • Featured Baked Goods

    Nutella Love Bites

    Half dozen of these sinfully delicious chocolate cookies, topped with a spoonful of Nutella and flecked with coarse sea salt.

  • Featured Baked Goods

    Cookies by the Dozen

    A variety pack of 1 dozen of our freshly baked cookies – including Nutella Love Bites, Triple Chocolate Chunkers, Old Fashioned Sprinklers, Peanut Butter’d, Sunflowers, Salted Caramel Snickerdoodles and Vegan Gingersnaps

  • Featured Baked Goods

    Super Fudge Brownies

    Half dozen, individually wrapped fudge brownies, studded with chocolate chips.

  • Featured Baked Goods

    Fudge Caramels

    12 pieces

@buttermilkbakeshopny

Featured Cake
Cranberry Carrot